Sort by:  Date | Most Recent | Top Rated

jeff ben and masky submitted by CreepyPastaBabe	creepypasta group submitted by FGthehedg3	SLENDER SONIC P1.) submitted by cartoonstuffer
SLENDER SONIC P1.) makeover submitted by cartoonstuffer	jeff the killer submitted by CreepyPastaBabe	Creepypasta Club submitted by usernameinvalid
mr skin and stitches (completed) submitted by FGthehedg3	mr skin and stitches submitted by FGthehedg3	Bloody wedding of Petra submitted by Perta-Ral
Creepypasta Petra Ral submitted by Perta-Ral	death of Petra Ral submitted by Foxy-grandpa	Creepy pasta Petra's death submitted by Foxy-grandpa
You shouldn't have done that submitted by IrishGamer1700	donald duck submitted by amy_the_killer	mickey mouse creepypasta submitted by amy_the_killer
hey! look! the best joke ever! submitted by FrostyBlazer	we're screwed submitted by FrostyBlazer	jeff the killer cat submitted by amy_the_killer
cry the monkey submitted by amy_the_killer	un dead rainbow dash submitted by amy_the_killer	ben brony, jeff brony and eyeless jack brony ^.^ submitted by aleiyavonvanity
my favorite pasta<3 submitted by aleiyavonvanity	BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127	BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127
BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127	BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127	BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127
BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127	BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127	BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127
BEN Drowned submitted by Ichigo127	Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127	Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127
Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127	Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127	Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127
Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127	Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127	Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127
Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127	Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127	Jeff the Killer submitted by Ichigo127
LOLOLOLOL submitted by SteamPunkOtaku	Slender SteamPunk submitted by SteamPunkOtaku	I Found The Creepiest Picture On The Internet submitted by SteamPunkOtaku
Ticci Toby (for Windwakerguy430) submitted by SteamPunkOtaku	not colored Jeff the killer submitted by MeboowYoshioka	Ben and Jeff and my oc Yoshi...... submitted by MeboowYoshioka
Uncolored Jeff the killer submitted by MeboowYoshioka	Ben Drowned submitted by MeboowYoshioka	Jeff the Killer submitted by MeboowYoshioka
jeff and sally submitted by SallyAcachalla	Slender Man submitted by popcat300	BEN Drowned 2 submitted by popcat300
BEN DDrowned submitted by popcat300	lol submitted by Killer-king	Smile.dog Colgate submitted by swampfox31
creepypasta family photo submitted by storm-shadow	People's views of Jeff the Killer submitted by Lifebloom	Cutest canon yaoi couple submitted by Fandom_Shipurrr
Mini Eyeless Jack submitted by diamond9201	jeff the killer submitted by 9000200	Right Place at the Wrong Time Pt. 5 submitted by Lancelot8
Right Place at the Wrong Time Pt. 4 submitted by Lancelot8	Right Place at the Wrong Time Pt. 3 submitted by Lancelot8	Right Place at the Wrong Time Pt. 2 submitted by Lancelot8
Right Place at the Wrong Time Pt. 1 submitted by Lancelot8	More of Jeff's info submitted by Lancelot8	Jeff's info submitted by Lancelot8
Now detects Jeff submitted by Lancelot8	He's looking up at you... submitted by Lancelot8	BEN and Jeff the Killer submitted by Lancelot8
Jeff on the floor submitted by Lancelot8	Jeff in Chains submitted by Lancelot8	What did you do Jeff? submitted by Lancelot8
Waiting for the shower submitted by Lancelot8	Shadow People submitted by Lancelot8	Having a tea party submitted by Lancelot8
Be in bed by 11 submitted by Lancelot8	Slenderman the angry chef of house wife like thing submitted by Lancelot8	Jeff The Killer submitted by Lancelot8
Jeff and Smile.dog submitted by Lancelot8	Eyeless, Jeff, and BEN submitted by Lancelot8	Jeff and Jane the Killer submitted by Lancelot8
CreepyPasta Group Photo submitted by Lancelot8	The Three Stages Of Jeff The Killer submitted by Lancelot8	Laughing Jack submitted by Lancelot8
Slendy and Jeff submitted by Lancelot8	Jeff The Killer submitted by Lancelot8	Bathing in Blood submitted by Lancelot8
Jeff the Killer submitted by Lancelot8	Sonic.exe with tongue out submitted by Lancelot8	Eyeless jack chibi submitted by toxic_venom
Slenderman chibi submitted by toxic_venom	Masky <3 chibi submitted by toxic_venom	Who needs eyes? submitted by FLUFFYMUFFIN
Ben drowned submitted by FLUFFYMUFFIN	SMILE DOG!!! o.o submitted by FLUFFYMUFFIN	Dora meets Happy Appy..... submitted by MightyMatt

skip question