Fanpressions The Fan Art criticism game :D

huddysmacked posted on May 09, 2010 at 07:35PM
This idea is basically like the forum of the icon concrit game only that this one is about fan art so Rule #1 NO icons please.

Rule #2 only constructive criticism!
Rule #3 HAVE FUN!

So for the one who don't know you post an image and says in what it could have been better. I'll start.
This idea is basically like the forum of the icon concrit game only that this one is about fan art so
last edited on May 09, 2010 at 07:37PM

Fanpressions 91 replies

Click here to write a response...
Next

Showing Replies 51-91 of 91

over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
*_________*perfect

oh.this fan art is so worst XDDD
*_________*perfect

oh.this fan art is so worst XDDD
over a year ago oblix said…
i think the lighting and colour in that piece is wonderful, however the rounded corners are distracting ..(i'm not sure if that's how fanpop displays it)

..i'm on wrong computer to display my work :/

lovehousemd_frv .. your 'light at the end of the tunnel' one is brilliant.
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago housefrk said…
So, I'll just critique the same one, I guess.

I agree that it's wonderful. I also agree about the rounded edges. It's great though.
So, I'll just critique the same one, I guess. 

I agree that it's wonderful. I also agree about the
over a year ago Paramore-CSI said…
sunny
I love iy exept the text is hard to read
I love iy exept the text is hard to read
over a year ago housefrk said…
The blurring is a little strange. Maybe if it were a little more gradual?
The blurring is a little strange. Maybe if it were a little more gradual?
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
I can't read the text.I can but so hard. i know.you not understand nothingXDDD.i lIKE it.

oh oblix .Thanks:3.And i'm jani.I know for the rounded things
I can't read the text.I can but so hard. i know.you not understand nothingXDDD.i lIKE it.

oh oblix
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
It's good but the text is a bit smaller. The coloring is perfect.
It's good but the text is a bit smaller. The coloring is perfect.
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
It'really sooooooooo good but maybe @the second pick we must see Greg better.Just in this way it looks just little strange but i like ans the colourins us perfect



This banner is so simply but i just not have time to make something:)
It'really sooooooooo good but maybe @the second pick we must see Greg better.Just in this way it look
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
I think overall is good but is too simple, maybe fill it with other things, I dunno.
I think overall is good but is too simple, maybe fill it with other things,  I dunno.
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
I love it^______^.

Yeah.I know for my banner.

And now this banner is "Blahhh"But i will make sometnhing other
last edited over a year ago
I love it^______^.

Yeah.I know for my banner.

And now this banner is "Blahhh"But i will make sometn
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
Blah? It's beautiful! I have no words!
Blah? It's beautiful! I have no words!
over a year ago thirteen_times said…
It's amazing. I think the first bit is abit bright compared to the end bit but other than that it's beautiful.
It's amazing. I think the first bit is abit bright compared to the end bit but other than that it's b
over a year ago Paramore-CSI said…
I loove it
last edited over a year ago
I loove it
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
Wooooo.I like it:)


I'm the most craziest girl@world.I'm makink christmas banners in sumerXDDD
Wooooo.I like it:)


I'm the most craziest girl@world.I'm makink christmas banners in sumerXDDD
over a year ago housefrk said…
I think the picture on the right is a little too bright compared to the picture on the left. I would match their skin tones a little more. It's really good though. I love the effects and the text is a great color.

V I know the quality of the screencap is bad. That's why I had to V make it so dark and I couldn't use more color.
I think the picture on the right is a little too bright compared to the picture on the left. I would
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
I like it a lot. Though yeah like you said, the first pic is really dark, but it's justified.
I like it a lot. Though yeah like you said, the first pic is really dark, but it's justified.
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
I like it and the way text shines♀________♀and colouring is perfect
but i not want to me rude but maybe if have a photo between other 2 banner will be more good;)
I like it and the way text shines♀________♀and colouring is perfect
but i not want to me rude but
over a year ago Paramore-CSI said…
♥♥♥♥♥♥♥I love everything about it!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
♥♥♥♥♥♥♥I love everything about it!!!!!♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
I like it though the images could have been blended better.
I like it though the images could have been blended better.
over a year ago thirteen_times said…
heart
love it, love beetlejuice
love it, love beetlejuice
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
I like it though the girl looks a bit blurry.
I like it though the girl looks a bit blurry.
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
I think everything is alright there:)
I think everything is alright there:)
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
It's perfect!
It's perfect!
over a year ago thirteen_times said…
The last bit of text is abit hard to read
The last bit of text is abit hard to read
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
I know it looks small, but the image is supposed to be bigger that's why the text looks so small....anyways

Are you trying to kill me here? It's perfect!
I know it looks small, but the image is supposed to be bigger that's why the text looks so small....a
over a year ago thirteen_times said…
Love it
Love it
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
I love this one!
I love this one!
over a year ago thirteen_times said…
mischievous
I just died of hotness. I love it.
I just died of hotness. I love it.
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
Pinnkkkkkk*becomes vampire*
*______*It's beautiful and i love the flowers>.<
Pinnkkkkkk*becomes vampire*
*______*It's beautiful and i love the flowers>.<
over a year ago Paramore-CSI said…
Love it so much, it's so mystical and magical looking
Love it so much, it's so mystical and magical looking
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
I like it a lot though the text might have had an outer glow so it could outstand a bit more.
I like it a lot though the text might have had an outer glow so it could outstand a bit more.
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
hmmm
I like it
...*watch*watch**watch*WTF is this green thing*stares*
I like it
...*watch*watch**watch*WTF is this green thing*stares*
over a year ago housefrk said…
The blending is really, really good, but the text is kind of hard to read
The blending is really, really good, but the text is kind of hard to read
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
I like everything but maybe "wicked" must be with another type of writing:)
I like everything but maybe [i]"wicked"[/i]  must be with another type of writing:)
over a year ago Paramore-CSI said…
I looove it
I looove it
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
It's good but too dark:)
It's good but too dark:)
over a year ago housefrk said…
The blending is great, but the way that the two middle pics are layers makes the person look kind of distorted.
last edited over a year ago
The blending is great, but the way that the two middle pics are layers makes the person look kind of
over a year ago lovehousemd_frv said…
i Loved this one.I like the fact that has used different styles of writing and the blue colour is amazing.Maybe the girls skin could be more lighter:)
i Loved this one.I like the fact that has used different styles of writing and the blue colour is ama
over a year ago huddysmacked said…
It's so very blurry.
It's so very blurry.
over a year ago thirteen_times said…
I love it though the word music is hard to see
I love it though the word music is hard to see
over a year ago Paramore-CSI said…
That is so freakin sexy and fantastic!!
That is so freakin sexy and fantastic!!