Confessions - The epilogue was like a bad fanfiction. I wish it wasn't ever written Poll Results - Harry James Potter

What do you think? Place your vote!

(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Harry James Potter Confessions - The epilogue was like a bad fanfiction. I wish it wasn't ever written

59 fans picked:

Disagree

63%

Agree

37%

makintosh posted over a year ago

Make your pick! | next poll >>

14 comments

	turturkeykey picked Disagree: I can't believe you said that!Anything Joanne has written is brilliant! posted over a year ago.

	quitepathetic picked Disagree: ^ Yeah! posted over a year ago.

	milky-way picked Disagree: It was fine, it's nice knowing what happened to them in the future. posted over a year ago.

	Schnusch picked Disagree: Disagree fully and completely! I loved it =) posted over a year ago.

	JAlanaE picked Disagree: I have to admit that I feel a little awkward about it too, but I don't wish that it had never been written because: 1. The more Harry Potter the better 2. I love the "bravest man I ever knew" quote about Snape 3. I don't want to miss this part of the movie But the names and the "all was well" were a little too cheesy for my taste. posted over a year ago.

	terhenetar picked Agree: The only thing about the epilogue that I like is the "bravest man I ever knew" quote. posted over a year ago.

	twilightlover73 picked Disagree: I'm going to quote a user I can't believe you said that! Anything Joanne has written is brilliant! because it's true. And I loved the epilogue, it was one of my favorite parts of the movie! But you do have a point somewhere, it felt quite awkward having to see Harry and the rest nineteen years later so quickly.... posted over a year ago.

	simpleplan picked Disagree: I loved the epilogue posted over a year ago.

	OnlyHarmioneHJP picked Agree: What?!?! That epilogue SUCKED!!!!! Sorry people, but it did. It was completely unrealistic! You mean to tell me these dysfunctional teenage couples actually stayed together for the rest of their lives?!?!? I call b*s*!!! That only happens in certain cases, and this sure wasn't one of them... And don't even get me started on the recycled kids names... things would have been so much better if left to the imagination. posted over a year ago.

	ArcticWolf picked Disagree: I loved the epilogue. I agree, though, it was written like fanfiction, I just don't care. I don't read books to learn anything, I read books to be entertained. The epilogue was interesting and it entertained me, and that's all I care about. posted over a year ago. last edited over a year ago

	hrrypttrfn328 picked Disagree: Wow, OnlyHarmioneHJP, calm down. It is called an opinion. I personally liked the epilogue, and did not think for a minute that the relationships were unrealistic. It's not like all of them marry their highschool sweethearts or anyhting, Draco didn't. How are they dysfunctional, by the way? posted over a year ago.

	tammy63 picked Agree: The thing I don't get about it was Harry talked to Albus, gave him a hug but what about James? He did'nt get anything. In the movie, there should have been a bit more conversation, not just appearances for appearance sake. posted over a year ago.

	Cailyn192 picked Disagree: Well jk couldnt just finish it off after the fight unless she produced another book so putting on this chapter is like tying up most loose ends but others needed to be told. It gives a general impression of what the main characters were doing or had done. I think its my favourite chapter of the books and reread it heaps! posted over a year ago.

	LowriLorenza89 picked Disagree: I actually like the epilogue. It was a nice piece of closure and it went full circle to the start of the books. The extra only thing I'd have liked is a brief mention of Luna in the same way Neville got a mention. It'd have been really weird, even though probably more realistic, if the 2 couples had separated and married new people by the time of the epilogue. We'd all be asking "who are these new people?". Readers and viewers get emotionally invested in the couples they see developing, so they want to see those couples happy at the end rather than a more realistic not-with-their-school-sweethearts scenario. posted over a year ago.