J.K Rowling vs Stephenie Meyer

answer this question

J.K Rowling vs Stephenie Meyer Question

How many of you think....

Don't you think it's unfair for SM to be compared to JK Rowling? I mean, on one side, you've got this brilliant British author, who made a whole new world of wizards, and on the other side, you have a woman who published her dreams. That's all I write about SM because if I got started... especially on sparkles!
*
who's the idiot that would compare duh .........? theres no one MEANING NO ONE like ROWLING in the world and there WON'T BE
BellaLovett posted over a year ago
*
i agree completely
superwalrus posted over a year ago
*
J.K. Rowling is amazing, you just gotta love her
zar_far11 posted over a year ago
 harrypotterbest posted over a year ago
next question »

J.K Rowling vs Stephenie Meyer Answers

superwalrus said:
They are completely different, but if you compare the amount of thought and effort put into the books, JKR wins by a mile. I mean, how can you vote SM didn't even make her main character, whom you should feel most atatched to, as boring as a piece of cardboard. I have read all Harry Potters and the first Twilight and for me I had to stop because I couldn't feel Bella's emotion or connect to her in any way, therefore i couldn't connect to her story. Both writers are very accomplished, and there are fans that will argue this point both ways, but thats just my view of it.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
bessmarvin1 said:
I know what u mean.I don't hate Twilight.There are somethings that I positively hate about Twilight,like the fact that Bella is a Mary Sue.And the sparkling thing.It was so.......gay.But I loved Edward and rest of the Cullens.But JKR is.....JKR.We cannot copare her with anyone else
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
alexia13 said:
sigh~ i know...
the only reason people started comparing jk and sm is because twilight has hot guys and romance so, crazy teenage twilight fans think twilight is better then hp in every way.
Jk is soooo much a better writer and a person then sm. Jk will be remembered as one of the best writers in the world.

 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
actually no thats not what all twilight fans like it for. the fans will like the romance of it all because thats what they are into. ok hot guys come as a bonus but i dont watch the twilights for that. i deeply love the story of it and the emotion of the characters and the pain that they have to go through
avrilsmylife posted over a year ago
cassie-1-2-3 said:
Nope, they're both obviously successful writiers, so...

Where they're from doesn't matter.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Bellatrix-Cissy said:
i tottaly agree!who is SM to be compared with Queen Rowling?!
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
avrilsmylife said:
hello you do know they are both fiction and made up. they are two cmpletly different storys that havee done well. i would understand if you were comparing two wizard books or two vampire books but like i said they are different. you cant say one is better when they ave both used imagination to make the books so potter fans think of that when you go to twilight fans and twilight fans the same. both book are fiction and made up by imagination that i love
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
completely agree!
cool1234girl posted over a year ago
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!