Kuroshitsuji

answer this question

Kuroshitsuji Question

Manga and Anime discussion.

I LOVE Black Butler/Kuroshitsuji but I just found the manga SO much better than the anime. There were so many things that the anime left out, like the Noah's Arc circus arc. I want to know your thoughts - were you disappointed with the anime? Or do you like how they've done it?
Manga and Anime discussion.
 PrincessHearts posted over a year ago
next question »

Kuroshitsuji Answers

maka243 said:
i like how they did it

 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Animeanimal said:
I like the anime as its own stand alone story. The manga is wonderful as well, but if your asking me which one is better, i am afraid i cant tell you.....true the manga is the original and usually i would pick the original over the edited revisioned version, but that is only because i HATE when someone takes a writer's story and messes it up. That is NOT the case with Black butler. The do everything in their power to stick to the characters personality's and overall story and made the anime, not a complete replica of the manga, but gave it their own fantastical twist and made the anime an extension of Yana Toboso's great work.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
true, i agree with you, I LOVE both the anime and manga. I did like the anime too, and it would've been better as a stand alone story but I love how the characters turned out. I think they stuck to the characterisation very well! Thanks for answering =D
PrincessHearts posted over a year ago
*
no prob
Animeanimal posted over a year ago
girpandababies said:
Im kind of on-and-off with the anime,exspecially the second season.They completely blew off the circus arc,trapped Sebastian in a contract forever,created something like claude and killed Alois (even though he got his happy ending)But i cant really bring myself to be dissapointed in anything Kuroshitsuji related(except Claude)
Besides the anime had its moments. Like how they decided who killed Ciel's parents,it was twisted and perfect!^^
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
haha i know what you mean! I love kuroshitsuji, it's amazing (with very awesome characters ;D) but yeah, it's just the changes from the manga to the anime i didn't like. that's why i prefer the manga. thank you for answering! :)
PrincessHearts posted over a year ago
saying_shiro said:
Yes, it's true. The anime and manga are stand alone stories. I have to say the I like the manga better. I really disliked the first season(anime), but I really liked the second season .Although alot of people said that the hated it.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
thank you for answering! t =o be honest i lke both the anime and manga, but i didn't like how they changed it and left out things, you know? thank you for answering! :D
PrincessHearts posted over a year ago
*
are u kidding? LOVE the second season X)
Animeanimal posted over a year ago
*
to be honest i haven't got around to watching the second season yet, but im really looking forwayd to it! :D
PrincessHearts posted over a year ago
sasuke_avenger said:
I like both the anime and the manga. But I'm disappointed in the anime that Ciel became a demon(spoiler) and Sebastian never got the soul he wanted and now that season 2 has ended. The manga isnt over yet. Plus I like the plot a lot more.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
yeah i like the plot of the manga a lot :) i love the anime too, don't get me wrong, but i wish they didn't change it too much from the anime :)
PrincessHearts posted over a year ago
Red_raven said:
They have circus now and I liked ( booth bolth?)....=/?
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!