i liked samantha but she's not part of the choices :(

you could have added her yourself

I would've said Dr. Vink (with a va! va!), but he wasn't a choice either....granted,he's not a campfire kid.

DAVID HAD THE SCARIEST CHOICES

I know David had the good ones lol

I dunno if Betty Anne was best, but the Mystical Mirror, as a girl scared the shit out of me enough to remember it till this day, so she gets my vote. Tucker, btw, had some good ones too.

David = scare. He had the best scare choices.

Betty Ann was a total creeper but I loved her anyway.

I remember thinking Eric was a douche.

I really loved BETTY ANN's stories. Especially mystical mirror.
That one scared the Bee Jesus out of me when i was a kid!!
I also love the subtle attraction between David and Kristen!!
David's stories were really good too!!

Really good show, but I only liked the animated ones when I was watching Nick back then.

3 way tied between Gary, Betty Ann, Kristen

i loved gary!

<3

i never seened it but i remember some shows i was just 5 yrs back then nd later where r the old shows. I MISS THEM!!

'Cause my name's Kristen, too. XP