Do you think Twilight would have been so popular if Robert Pattinson wasn't in it? The story is good but without him it wouldn't be the same!

Yeah, i think it would be the same...just whoever was playing Edward would have all the attention of the fangirls instead of Rob Pattinson. Whoever played Edward would be the one people have a huge crush on, its the character of him girls like which make everyone love him. thats what i think anyway...

I think it would be the same....we'll be ''in love''in another actor like we are in Rob..:))so,I think it would be the same....story is to Edward Cullen not to actor who plays him!:P

yeah it would still have been good,but i'm sure glad robby got the part of edward because i just cann't picture it without him.

Honestly, i think twilight would be BETTER without Rob because he doesn't seem like a good Edward 2 me. I know they couldn't possibly pick an Edward that everybody that reads twilight would agree with but he just doesn't seem like the right guy to play the part. I don't even like the movies that much because they take to much stuff out. The books are AMAZING though. In my defense I am just way too in love with the Edward in my head i think its unhealthy.LOL

no lo se... Roberth es genial como actor pero antes de Twilight para mi su trabajo era irrelevante, asi que supongo q para el representa una gran oportunidad de crecer ... ha hecho un buen trabajo y si, quizas no hubiera sido lo mismo pero quizas hubiera sido mejor.. I LOVE ROB!

i think it would be the same.. i read twilight before there was going to be a movie and my friends and i were so excited when a film was announced so i think we would have been happy with it anyway.

Yes because Twilight was populer before the movie and even if Rob was not in it I think it would still be populer with someone else but not as populer it is now......

Robert pattison is the star in twilight i don't think twilight would have been the same without him so i can't wait for stephenie meyer to bring the twilght series from edwards side!

i think it would be the same but not as good; people wouldnt be as obsessed as they are now; it would just be another crazy love movie. Rob brings something unique to the movie; like his personality. & it helps that he has stunningly good looks :)

i think so, because in the beginning, most of the fans didn't even like rob!

I think it would have had the same popularity with or without Robert Pattinson.
Everyone, even me, fell in love with Edward Cullen, before we knew that he was going to be portrayed by Robert Pattinson, in the movie.
But I was honestly jumping around my house in excitement, when I heard Rob was going to be in the movie (:
But either way, and with or without Robert, I think it would still have had the same amount of popularity.
-xo.

of course it would have been popular without robert!!i don't think he is the best actor in the film and i think that what made the film so popular is the beautiful enchanting story,not the actors...and if i have to admit kristen is much better like an actor than robert

it probably would be populare......but not as populare as it is right now if robert wasnt in it

It wouldnt have been as good without him I think he was born for this part.