What do you think? Place your vote!
(Placed your vote already? Remember to login!)

Sirius Black Do you think Gary Oldman truly looks like Sirius Black?

285 fans picked:
Yeah, he does
   40%
No way!
   27%
Yes... and no!
   19%
(added by namfesis)
I dont know
I dont know
   7%
(added by LBR)
At least when I´ ve read the books my image of...
At least when I´ve read the books my image of Sirius was something like Gary Old
   6%
(added by Brysis)
I usually imagine Ben Barnes but I do love Gary's version!
   0%
(added by Eirien)
 SilentRevelry posted over a year ago
Make your pick! | next poll >>
save

44 comments

user photo
ilovehinder picked Yeah, he does:
shut yo facees ppl seriously how he looked in the movie is how i pictured him wen i read the book. i didnt picture him as some skinny-ass shaved guy who looked good.
seriously. if he were in prison for 12 years, would he be shaved and handsome? no
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SilentRevelry picked No way!:
Geez, calm down
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Jillywinkles picked No way!:
I pictured him without a beard and straighter hair, but that's just me. I also imagined him slightly different to the way Gary Oldman portrayed him acting-wise, but again that's just me and I don't think Oldman did a bad job of the role.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
eliza_romanov picked Yeah, he does:
I like Gary Oldman, but I think the script isn`t good. I`m very disappointed in movies, especially with the last one...
Movies suck! Books are much better...
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SilentRevelry picked No way!:
Well, for one thing I imagined him with black hair; crazy hair but not curly hair. I thought his hair was straight and frazzled because of Azkaban. I was pretty sure he had grey eyes.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
siriusllyalgood picked Yeah, he does:
Gary looks freakin HOT! They def picked the right guy!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
zuntiz picked No way!:
I think Oldman is a good actor, but in my opinion they could have choosen someone else for Sirius, perhaps someone slightly younger, and unknown.
Then for how Sirius is acting in the movies, then I can't blame him so much, he just followed the script (hopefully...)
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
x-xsarahx-x picked Yeah, he does:
he so wasnt in the movies enough!! he did really good though.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
drpeppergrl321 picked Yeah, he does:
ilovehinder is right!!!
and so is xxsarahxx
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
nathboleyn picked No way!:
I agree with zuntiz, gary is a great actor but I wouldn't choose him to be sirius. I pictured him as viggo mortesen, I think.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
tooch picked Yeah, he does:
that's pretty much how i picture him in the book before i saw the movie.

-xo.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Melissa666 picked No way!:
I pictured him to be much better looking.
posted over a year ago.
last edited over a year ago
 
user photo
Lady_Togo picked Yes... and no!:
of course he does!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
kerikeri picked No way!:
no i think Johnny Depp more better!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
katycullen09 picked No way!:
i rekon that i prefer him how i pictured him, but he was how i piked him personality wise.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
67impala picked No way!:
Not even close to the way I pictured Sirius! Gary is a fantastic actor, and looked pretty hot when he was younger. But he was about 20 years older than Sirius would have been. Sirius was still a young man - only in his early thirties. There are some incredibly handsome actors out there in their thirties and forties! They should have chosen someone younger and handsomer, and made him look somewhat ravaged by his years at Azkaban.

I agree with zuntiz. An unknown would have been the way to go. I hate to say it, but sometimes I think directors prefer to rely on a big name rather than find someone who truly fits the part.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
ShadowRocksxxx picked No way!:
i don't like the way they portray sirius in the movies AT ALL!! they have completely changed his character! very disappointing.

i realise that sirius would not be clean-shaven, etc after being in azkaban for twelve years, but i don't like the idea of him keeping the long hair and moustache. and i don't like the way he dresses, in those suits (i thought he wanted to be different from his family? perhaps he didn't have much of a choice in clothes, after being in azkaban for so long.)

gary oldman is too old to be sirius, i have said that before and i will say it again!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
I dont know
BaSbooSa picked I dont know:
Because I didn't read the books..
but even if I didn't I like Gary Oldman as Sirius Black = )
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
life_rehab picked Yeah, he does:
gary oldman is the perfect sirius black!
he's exactly how i've pictured him while reading the books:X:X
and, yeah...the books are way better!!!!!!!

posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
true_katex picked Yeah, he does:
deffinately!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
At least when I´ ve read the...
BellatrixCissy picked At least when I´ve read the books my image of Sirius was something like Gary Old:
maybe less of a beard then he got my vote and don't think i'm saying that to make ppl happy i mean don't ask for my real opinion of sirius you'll wana kill me look at my username it'll give u a hint.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
kichiv picked No way!:
yeah i don't think curls match Sirius that much, and i most definitely pictured him to be taller with bangs like the illustrations suggest. When they came out with the movie i was very much looking forward to that moment when Sirius was hinting for Harry to move into his home and Harry so heartily agreed and Sirius smiled with a smile that reminded Harry of what he saw in pictures. There wasn't even a smile! And Gary Oldman appears elegant as Sirius, I pictured Sirius to be a little more gruff, and maybe a hint of mischief lol... Besides, I know he's not American Indian or Asian or something of the sort, but there ARE some men out there whose chins are naturally (or somewhat) less hairy and are still manly. I also pictured him without a beard.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
hrrypttrfn328 picked No way!:
He was pretty vividly pictured in the books, having matted long black hair, sunken grey eyes, the appearence of a skeleton, Gary Oldman, even though he did a good job as Sirius, is VERY different then the physical description given in the books.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
kwlski4ever picked No way!:
Gary is a great actor . .
But not exactly how I imagined Sirius.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
EalasaidWooster picked No way!:
Nah, I don't think he suits Sirius!!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
StichxAngel4eva picked Yeah, he does:
totally.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
wiccakitty picked Yeah, he does:
when they said they were making the books into films.the actor I thought of for sirius was gary Oldman! hes perfect! but they havent used him enough,as hes such a great character.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
LifesGoodx3 picked Yeah, he does:
Yeah... He was great. I just wish we saw more Sirius in the movies :/
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SiriusBlack101 picked Yeah, he does:
When I saw the movie I was like OMG ITS SIRIUS BLACK! LOL then I had 2 remind myself that Sirius isn't actually reel...lol. yeah..they picked the rite guy 4 Sirius! :) GARY OLDMAN ROX!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
SiriusSeverus picked Yeah, he does:
Yeah, he does. The Sirius on the posters scared me... and that's okay, because (as someone else already said) he just broke out of prison...
Then the 'cleaned up' Sirius appeared... and yeah, I think he looks pretty much as I figured he would. Also, I think (in the little screen time he did get) he portrayed him really well.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Sprinter23 picked Yeah, he does:
Sirius is like one of my top 5 favorite characters!!! And Gary Oldman does an AMAZING job as him.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Starrlightx3 picked No way!:
He looks nothing like the way I picture Sirius in my head, in all honesty.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
i-am-mariella picked Yeah, he does:
He looks a bit like Sirius in my head. The Sirius in my head had the same bedraggled hair and kind of tired look you would get from being in Azkaban, like he does in the film, like Bellatrix does... I thought of him as a bit younger though, but I probably prefer him this way.
@kerikeri: I don't think Johnny Depp would have done the role justice. He's a bit too clean-shaven...I mean, even in Sweeney Todd he was still like that, relatively...(well, he was playing a barber, silly me.) But I'd prefer a proper British actor, like Gary, than an American one no matter how good they are at playing British roles, because Sirius and most of the roles except maybe Susan Bones in the movie were British. Besides, we already have the lovely Helena Bonham Carter and the shrunken head. If we add Johnny into the mix it might as well be a Tim Burton film.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Darkshine picked Yes... and no!:
The only thing I imagined differently was darker hair.
But Gary Oldman was perfect anyway.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
ecpjll picked Yeah, he does:
yup
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
ncisminiziva07 picked No way!:
No, in the book it said he had black hair...but he in a way, did kind of look like Sirius Black.
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
At least when I´ ve read the...
Thecharliejay picked At least when I´ve read the books my image of Sirius was something like Gary Old:
hes awesome
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
At least when I´ ve read the...
PikaPikaKuro picked At least when I´ve read the books my image of Sirius was something like Gary Old:
I love Gary Oldman because he is Sirius Black ;D
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
At least when I´ ve read the...
angiii7 picked At least when I´ve read the books my image of Sirius was something like Gary Old:
I love how Gary Oldman plays Sirius, he's just genius!
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
joe411 picked No way!:
He looks nothing like Gary Oldman
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
Padfoot6501 picked Yes... and no!:
Yes...And no Sirius was supossed to be really handsome but I think Gary's acting made up for it
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
CrazyCatLady picked Yeah, he does:
I loved Gary Oldman has Sirius Black! and Gary Oldman is very very handsome! :)
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
teacupitty43 picked Yeah, he does:
HELL yeah
posted over a year ago.
 
user photo
katieparker picked No way!:
No, and anyone who does didn't read the books carefully enough. Now don't get me wrong I love Gary Oldman as much as the next person and thought he did a wonderful job, but he looks nothing like Sirius. Sirius had long naturally black hair (not dyed or gothic as some would have you believe natural and ceartinaly not wavy brown), aristocratic cheekbones, and piercing grey eyes (not brown like some will claim, grey eyes is a canon fact). He was tall really tall, he is described as at least a head taller then Snape and as height is never a described trait of Lupin was can assume he was taller then him as well. Sirius was supposed to be physically imposing even as an undernourished prisoner so I always saw him as tall thin but broad shoulders showing how powerful he could be. He was only in his late thirties for goodness sake, yes Azkaban made him look older but an old looking thirty year old does not look in his late fifties (not that Gary is old just older then Sirius and don't get me started on 22 year old James and Lily grrr), their should have been moments where you could see his true age like when he smiles for the first time. Gary gave a wonderful performance but to claim he looks like the Sirius described in the books is grossly inaccurate.
posted over a year ago.