Stephenie Meyer

answer this question

Stephenie Meyer Question

I Have A Challenge! Are You In?

I Love Harry Potter And Twilight! In My Opion, They're Equals! So I Joined The "Twilight vs. Harry Potter" Fan Club! I Was Hoping To Find Someone Who Thought The Same Way As Me! I Didn't Find It! What I Did Find, Is Shocking!

I Looked At A Question That Says "I think Twilight is better than Harry Potter, agree?" The Comments Were So Amazingly Rude! I Want To Come To Twilight's Defence!

A Girl Said That "Harry Potter actually has 1,000 reasons why it's better than Twilight." (they actually do have a post of that on the "Harry Potter" fan club) "No Twilight lover can actaully give 1,000 reasons why they love it. They just say, 'Because Edward Cullen is sexy' and 'Jacob Black has nice abs'"

I Don't Agree To What She Said! I Left Her A Comment Telling Her I'd Give Her 1,000 Reasons Why We Love Twilight!

So, Twilight Fans, This Is Up To You! Please Give Me As Many Reasons As You Want! I Need At Least 1,000! (I could do it by myself-because Twilight is great, but I want some more fans in on it)

So Are You In?

Please Note That Any Reasons That Say That Twilight Is Better Than Harry Potter, Will Not Be Used! Think Of It As This- I'm Team Switzerland For The Harry Potter vs. Twilight Thing!

This Post Will Be On All The Twilight Fan Clubs I'm In! So If You See This On More Than One Club, Don't Be Surprised!

It Doesn't Matter What Team You're On, It Matters If You Truly Love Twilight, You'll Help! :)

I Have A Challenge! Are You In?
 shivers-zimmy posted over a year ago
next question »

Stephenie Meyer Answers

harrypotterbest said:
Like I told you on another spot, Twilight doesn't stand a chance! You see, that's why all the fans are hiding because they know they don't stand a chance. Harry Potter is better, everyone knows that. HP fans have a lot more to discuss about. Also, HP fans can come up with more reasons than 'Draco is hot!!!!!!' which, in any way, would not count. It would be nice if you people actually tried, but you don't! Some reasoned debate is all we wanted, but you have to come up with some good reasons. And some of the Twilight fans here are even bigger HP fans.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Hey Now, I Debate Plenty! And Why Are You Here If You Hate "Twilight" So Much?
shivers-zimmy posted over a year ago
*
I needed to ask the Twilight fans a question about SM ^_^
harrypotterbest posted over a year ago
Hiding 3 comments... click to show.
*
Haha!
Monrose posted over a year ago
djsheshe said:
I like both and Harry Potter was my first love, but in Twilight's defence,

1. Bella as a main character is more real, we can all relate to her, Harry is just...dodge. he knows he's a really brave guy but he acts way to modest to the point of irritation.

2. The music rocks and u can honestly say you listen to it

3.Harry ran on for far to long, i may have cried, but there was a little relief in there.

4. Even tho books never do movies justice,(including twilight.) the Harry movies sucked to the point of... i dont know (the fourth one was the best not cuz rob was in it, but cuz it just was really good BUT...) they were horrible, i was sooo disappointed, but with Twilight, there is still something to look forward to in the movies.

4. The characters for me are better, i can relate to them more

5. Harry is too modest, it gets irritating. not that he should be a show off, but a its like he doesnt appreciate what he can do

6. Bella Swan, is more like any other girl there is. (except for the vampire boyfriend part)

7. Hermione tries to act too perfect sometimes. I like her but come on!

8. Don't lie and say that you dont't like the shirtlessness because if u do, u are a big fat liar. ok, LIAR!!!!! everyone loves it ok.

9. Alice is sweet and is someone you could actually see as your friend.

10. I can honestly say, the minute i picked up the book, i was hooked. i read the books before the movies and i was really taken to another world. Harry took some time for me to adjust too.

11. I watched Harry when i was young and frankly, i was mortified!!!!! its creepy, OK.


BUT..... i like both and i think we shouldnt take this too seriously, cuz eveyone likes something different to the next person.

Even tho its by like 10% i still think twilight is better. :P and besides, something else is gonna come out and eclipse(ha:D) the two eventually so...
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I Never Said I Don't Like The Shirtlessness! Trust Me, I Do! But It's Not Really A Valid Reason! And Thanks! :)
shivers-zimmy posted over a year ago
*
OK, first of all, most of these are the same. 5, 6, and 1 are the same. 1. Bella is relatable, well, tell me one way you can relate to her. And ‘acts way too modest,’ well, would you rather him saying ‘I’m the best! I defeated a Basilisk!’ or bragging that much? Modest is better in my opinion. As for number two, what do you mean by the music? Number 3, ‘Harry ran on for too long,’ what do you mean by this? If you mean the 7 books, then, once again, it’s opinion. Some people like more books to a series, some don’t. 4. We were talking about the books. ‘Even though the books never do movies justice,’ you’ve got it reverse. #4 [again] ‘For me,’ this is the key. And you can relate to them how? Please use facts from the book to support your answer. EX, I can relate to Hermione because, like Hermione, I want good grades in my school. 7 Don’t we all try to be perfect? Hermione only tries to get the best grades possible. 8. First, not everyone loves shirt-less-ness. 9. Alice is sweet, well, so are Ginny, Tonks, Hermione, Mrs. Weasley, and many more. They could all be your BFFs too. 10. This applies to you. I can honestly say the minute I started reading I was hooked on HP. Also, you say you were hooked once you [i]picked up[/i] the book. I thought you had to read it to be hooked? I could be wrong though. 11, How is Harry creepy? Really. Facts from the book please. I can say ‘Edward is creepy.’ I need reason to back it up, so I can add, ‘He is creepy because he stalks Bella.’ However, thanks for trying. Appreciate it.
harrypotterbest posted over a year ago
Hiding 2 comments... click to show.
*
To Harrypotterbest: Sorry, zoohi is funny.
shivers-zimmy posted over a year ago
Monrose said:
Well, I'm not a Twilight fan, so no... I actually have to agree with the Potter fans, although I didn't really like those books either.

I can, however, say the one good thing about Twilight: Jacobs body!! Even though it's fake on the cover of New Moon.
 select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!