Interesting list. How's this: His Band and Street Choir (5); Magic Time (6); What's Wrong With This Picture (5); Hymns to the Silence (9); Moondance (9); Hard Nose the Highway (4); Keep it Simple (8); Skiffle Session (5); Phiosopher's Stone (7); Days Like This (7) ; Veedon Fleece (9)

What's with "Hard Nose the Highway" given a 4???? It's an underrated album. Listen to his again.

My contribution -
Period of Transition - 3
Live in San Fransisco - 8
Inarticulate Speech of the Heart - 8
Hard Nose the Highway - 6
You Win Again - 2
Magic Time - 7
Back on Top - 7
Veedon Fleece - 10
Moondance - 10
Van at the Movies - 9
Astral Weeks - 10
No Guru No Method No Teacher - 9
Keep it Simple - 8
Enlightenment - 9
Hymns to the Silence - 8
Poetic Champions Compose - 7

10/10 - Veedon Fleece, Astral Weeks, Moondance, Enlightenment,
9/10 - Keep it Simple, No Guru, St Dominics, Common One,
8/10 - Avalon Sunset, Hymns, Down the Road, Days Like This

Keep it Simple - 9
Veedon Fleece - 10
Astral Weeks - 10
Moondance - 10
Common One - 9
St Dominic's Preview - 8
Hard Nose the Highway - 7

Here's what I think - just a girl's opinion you know, and the opinions of girls don't count much in rock:

Beautiful Vision - 8
Back on Top - 7
Down the Road - 7
Too Long in Exile - 8
No Guru, No Method, No Teacher - 9
Period of Transition - 2
Philosopher's Stone - 9
Moondance - 10
Astral Weeks - 10
Enlightenment - 10
Skiffle Sessions - 4
You Win Again - 1
Pay the Devil - 3
Hymns to the Silence - 10
Common One - 9
Hard Nose the Highway - 6
Poetic Champions Compose - 9
Wavelength - 8
His Band and Street Choir - 6
St Dominic's Preview - 8
Veedon Fleece - 10
Magic Time - 7
What's Wrong with this Picture? - 5
Live in San Fancisco - 9
Live in Belfast - 8

Here's my list:

Keep it Simple - 8
Blowin' Your Mind - 6
Beautiful Vision - 8
Back on Top - 8
Down the Road - 8
Too Long in Exile - 9
No Guru, No Method, No Teacher - 10
Period of Transition - 2
Philosopher's Stone - 10
Moondance - 10
Astral Weeks - 10
Enlightenment - 10
Skiffle Sessions - 4
You Win Again - 2
Pay the Devil - 3
Hymns to the Silence - 10
Common One - 9
Hard Nose the Highway - 7
Poetic Champions Compose - 9
Wavelength - 7
His Band and Street Choir - 5
St Dominic's Preview - 9
Veedon Fleece - 10
Magic Time - 7
What's Wrong with this Picture? - 5
Live in San Francisco - 9
Live in Belfast - 8

All are great. Everyone's opinion is different.

I have every album. Here are some .....

Blowin Your Mind - 5
Astral Weeks - 10
Moondance - 10
His Band and Street Choir - 7
Tupelo Honey - 9
St Dominic's Preview - 9
Veedon Fleece - 10
No Guru, No Method, No Teacher - 9
Period of Transition - 2
Philosopher's Stone - 9
Enlightenment - 10
Skiffle Sessions - 5
You Win Again - 1
Pay the Devil - 3
Hymns to the Silence - 10
Common One - 9
Hard Nose the Highway - 7
Poetic Champions Compose - 9
Wavelength - 8
Magic Time - 7
What's Wrong with this Picture? - 5
Beautiful Vision - 8
Back on Top - 8
Down the Road - 7
Too Long in Exile - 8
Live in San Francisco - 9
Live in Belfast - 8
Astral Weeks Live - 9

No Guru, No Method, No Teacher - 10
Blowin Your Mind - 6
Astral Weeks - 10
Moondance - 10
His Band and Street Choir - 6
Tupelo Honey - 7
St Dominic's Preview - 10
Veedon Fleece - 10
Period of Transition - 2
Philosopher's Stone - 9
Enlightenment - 10
Skiffle Sessions - 5
You Win Again - 3
Pay the Devil - 6
Hymns to the Silence - 10
Common One - 10
Hard Nose the Highway - 8
Poetic Champions Compose - 9
Wavelength - 9
Magic Time - 8
What's Wrong with this Picture? - 5
Beautiful Vision - 7
Back on Top - 8
Down the Road - 7
Too Long in Exile - 8
Live in San Francisco - 9
Live in Belfast - 8
Astral Weeks Live - 9
Keep it Simple - 8
Born to Sing - 8

Just to disagree with the other piddler:

Astral Weeks 10
Moondance 9
Best of Volume I 9
Still on Top 9
Veedon Fleece 9
No Guru, No Method, No Teacher 9
St Dominic's 9
Too Late to Stop Now 9
Philosopher's Stone 9
Common One 9
Enlightenment 9

Hymns to the Silence 8
Healing Game 8
Best of Volume III 8
Wavelength 8
Hard Nose the Highway 8
Poetic Champions Compose 8
Magic Time 8
Live in San Francisco 8
Beautiful Vision 8
Back on Top 8
Down the Road 8
Too Long in Exile 8

Live in Belfast 7
Avalon Sunset 7
Best of Volume II 7
Keep it Simple 7
Duets 7
Born to Sing No Plan B 7
His Band and Street Choir 7
Tupelo Honey 7
Blowing Your Mind 7
Inarticulate speech of the Heart 7
Astral Weeks Live 7

Period of Transition 6
Skiffle Sessions 6
Pay the Devil 6

You Win Again 5
What's Wrong with this Picture? 5
How Long Has this Been Going On 5

I like them all. But Common One, Keep Me Singing, St Dominic's Preview are all 10s.

I think only Astral Weeks and Moondance rate a 10 unless you count compilations like Best of Volume 1 and Still on Top. Those two compilations have some of the finest music around. Keep Me Singing is in that next bracket of albums that includes St Dominic's, Veedon Fleece, Too late to stop Now, etc. They're all nines.

Astral Weeks 10
Moondance 10
Veedon Fleece 10

Keep Me Singing 9
Best of Volume I 9
Still on Top 9
No Guru, No Method, No Teacher 9
St Dominic's 9
Too Late to Stop Now 9
Philosopher's Stone 9
Common One 9
Enlightenment 9
Wavelength 9
Hymns to the Silence 9
Healing Game 9

Latest Record Project Vol 1 8
Best of Volume III 8
Hard Nose the Highway 8
Poetic Champions Compose 8
Magic Time 8
Live in San Francisco 8
Beautiful Vision 8
Back on Top 8
Down the Road 8

Three Chords and the Truth 7
Too Long in Exile 7
Live in Belfast 7
Avalon Sunset 7
Roll With the Punches 7
Best of Volume II 7
Keep it Simple 7
Duets 7
Tupelo Honey 7
Blowing Your Mind 7
Inarticulate speech of the Heart 7
Astral Weeks Live 7

Born to Sing No Plan B 6
His Band and Street Choir 6
Versatile 6
Period of Transition 6
Skiffle Sessions 6
Pay the Devil 6

You Win Again 5
What's Wrong with this Picture? 5
How Long Has this Been Going On 5