I'm writing a mystery story on fanfiction.net and I need to come up with names for my two bad guys. The names i've considered are Brandon Anderson, Rafael Vasquez, Johnathan Maudsley, Kevin Smythe and Andrew Maudsley. Which two are best?

I don't think it's important to tell you which show the story is for but if you ask I will, the storyline: The main bad guy went on one date with the narrarator, but she didn't think they had anything in common so she stands him up on the second date. Instead that night, she gets drunk and ends up being romantically involved with her closest guy friend (lets call him Bobby). The next day the main bad guy comes to confront her and catches Bobby leaving. He's so enraged, that him and his best friend (the other bad guy) plan to abduct and murder him. However, they accidently kill the wrong guy, a John Gehring who looks like Bobby except without a beard. Eventually they actually abduct Bobby and the narrarator is racing to rescue him. (I know, weird and chaotic)