One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 101-150 of 1410

over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Quentin

Nathan/Clay or Nathan/Quentin?
over a year ago Shanice_12 said…
Nathan/Clay, although I love Nathan/Quentin.

Shirtless Nathan or Shirtless Clay?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
nathannn

Mouths cheerleading dance or Haley slapping rachel?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
mouths cheerleading danceeee

lucas shooting the basketball with the blind fold or nathan shooting without looking ??
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Nathan shooting without looking!

Bitchy Haley or Judgmental Haley? (don't worry I luv her!)
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Bitchy Haley.

Lucas` 'I`m the one for you' speech to Brooke or Lucas` second proposal to Peyton? (The one where Peyton said yes.)
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
I loved both but think I'm gunna have to the say the "I'm the one for you" speech. Which is a real shocker as I'm a leyton fan but I don't mind brucas and i loved that speech. I best post comment before I change my mind lolz. Sorry for the babbling....

Worst hair for the boys I think was season 4
Who's was worse nathan or lucass?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
nathannnnnnnn

lucas with a shaved head or nathan with a shaved head??
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
hmmmm...... Nathan

While were on the hair topic
Peytons or brookes in season one?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
peytonsssss

haley's hair blonde or brown ??
over a year ago J-C said…
Blonde.

Dan's basketball days or Karen's cheerleading days?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Dan's basketball days :)

Nathan & Jamie or Lucas & Sawyer?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Nathan + Jamie

With or without Leyton?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
with<3

brooke and rachel roomies or brooke and haley roomies ??
over a year ago J-C said…
Brooke and Rachel.

Haley screaming on a bridge or Peyton collapsing to the ground?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Peyton collapsing to the ground! But both were intense.

Peyton's fight with Nikkie or Brooke's fight with Rachel?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
Brooke's fight with rachellll...

brooke's outfits through season 1-7 or peytons??
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Probebly Brooke tho I do love P. Sawyer

Haleys fear of clowns or skills fear of animals?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
haleys fear for clowns.

taylor or quinn ?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Quinn

Season 2 newbies anna + felix or season 7 newbies clay + Quinn?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Grr... I guesse Season 7 newbies.

Jenny or Sawyer?
over a year ago J-C said…
Sawyer.

Tric or Karen's Cafe?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
hmmmm Karens cafe?

High school years or grown up years?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
high school yearssss!<33333

peyton punching brooke or brooke slapping peyton in season 4 ??
over a year ago laughingGrl said…
sunny
uh... peyton punching brooke, she looked so mad. :)

Pregnant haley or pregnant peyton?
over a year ago J-C said…
Pregnant Haley.

Millie as a secretary or Millie as a model?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
I've only seen one episode of her as a model so il say secretary.

Brucas or Leyton?
over a year ago Eryn6232150 said…
Leyton!!!

B. Davis or Brookie
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
b. davis <3

brooke high in season 7 or season 1
over a year ago Eryn6232150 said…
Season 1 LOL


Naley Wedding # 2 or Leyton Wedding??
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Naley Wedding #2 I think.... (it's close)

Jamie season 5/6/7 ( I don't care if it outta three lmao)

over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Jamie season 5! (he wuz actually cute)

Skills and Peyton or Skills and Haley?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
skills & haley

naley "dont say i never gave you anything" moment or leyton "you don't know me" moment
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Leyton "you don't know me" moment.

Paley or Brachel?
over a year ago laughingGrl said…
big smile
Paley

Brooke&Nate or Peyton&Nate (friends)
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Peyton and Nate

Alex or Nikki?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Nikki I think.

Cheerleading tournament season 1 or 3?

over a year ago tmenne23 said…
season 3

which out of the 7 seasons has the best first episode?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
6 il say....

Jake or Chris Keller?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Jake

Quinn or Peyton?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
PEYTON

Karen with Andy or Keith?
over a year ago nikiebaby said…
Karen with Andy

OTH with leyton or without leyton
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Definatly with Leyton <3

Junk or Fergie
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Fergie

Skills or Mouth?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
mouthhh

the comet or an unkindness of ravens ??
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
The comet

Tree Hill Ravens or the Charlotte bobcats
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
tree hill ravens<3

lucas's speech to brooke in the rain (seas 3) or nathan's speech to haley in the rain (seas 1) ??
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Nathans to haleys

Paley or braley?
over a year ago nikiebaby said…
Baley

Brucas or Brulian
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Brulian

Jeyton or Pulian?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!