One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 301-350 of 1410

over a year ago notimetosleep said…
Nathan and Dan

Season 3 Nathan or season 3 Brooke
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Season 3 Nathan.

Mia and Chase or Clay and Quinn?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Clay & Quinn

Naley vows or Leyton vows?
over a year ago Team_Brooke said…
heart
Naley vows!!! <3

Jamie's 5th or 7th birthday?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
5th birthday :)

Hot Uncle Cooper or Chris Keller?
over a year ago J-C said…
Chris Keller.

Haley puking on Dan's lap or Haley getting an F on her English test?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
haley puking on dan's lap ! :]

naley getting caught by dan, drunk, on the dock or nathan proposing on the dock?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Nathan proposing on the dock.

Peyton finding out Luke proposed to Lindsey or Luke finding out Brooke and Felix are together?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Luke finding out Brooke and Felix are together - the other much more sad :(

Leyton reunion 6x01 or Brulian reunion 7x18?
over a year ago truffethedog said…
Leyton reunion in 6x01

Larry Sawyer or Victoria Davis?
over a year ago girly_girl said…
Victoria!


Season 2 opening episode or Season 5 opening episode?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
season 2 opening

brooke and jamie or brooke and angie?
over a year ago girly_girl said…
Brooke and Angie! {I loved her! So cute!}


Season 5 Brooke or Season 6 Brooke?
over a year ago Team_Brooke said…
Season 5 Brooke (Hard to say!)

Feel This by Bethany or You Can't Break A Broken Heart by Kate
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Feel this<3

Peyton/Julian or Peyton/Pete?
over a year ago J-C said…
Peyton and Pete.

Dan saving Keith and Lucas from the car crash or Nathan teaching Haley how to do a free throw?
over a year ago taylor_swift123 said…
kiss
nathin teaching haley how to do a free throw
over a year ago J-C said…
^ Umm did Kanye take your mike away? Because you forgot to make the next one.
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Ok... So I'll just answer and make one up.

I also choose Nathan teaching Haley how to free throw.


Peyton breaking up with Lucas or Lucas breaking up with Brooke?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
tough one...but lucas breaking up with brooke

naley with jamie or without jamie?
over a year ago notimetosleep said…
without Jamie

Rachel&Bevin or Mouth&Shelley from the episode Pictures of you(4x13)?
over a year ago Lisiii said…
Rachel&Bevin ( =

road trip to Rachel's parents' cabin (s3) or road trip to Honeygrove (s4)?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Road trip to Honeygrove :)

Season one Nathan or season four Nathan?
over a year ago notimetosleep said…
Season 1 Nathan.

Peyton's drawings or Haley's music?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
peyton's drawings

brooke as a crab lady or haley as a waitress ?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
lmfao Brooke as a crab ! soo funny

Jake in s1/2 or s3
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Jake in season 1/2.

Nathan as a jerk or Lucas as a jerk?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Nathan! he was so hot as one xD

Brooke in season one or four?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Brooke in s4 ofc :D

Naley or Brulian ?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
Naley ! ♥

millie and mouth or millie and owen?
over a year ago J-C said…
Millie and Mouth.

Haley singing to Nathan in Karen's Cafe or Brooke catching Peyton and Lucas on Peyton's web cam?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Haley singing to Nathan in Karen's Cafe ♥

USO concert or Haley's concert in 7x13?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
USO concert.


Peyton and Nathan making out in the car or Chase and Brooke doing it in the car?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
chase and brooke doing it in the car..plus the blooper for that is hilarious!

"always and forever" or "true love always?"
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
"always and forever!!!"

"I'm not the guy for you Brooke Davis" or "I hate you Peyton, you ruined my life"?
over a year ago Lisiii said…
"I hate you Peyton" haha xD

Sparkle Classic 1x17 (I dunno...was it Sparkle Classic? Whatever...there was a tournament xD) or Sparkle Classic 3x14?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago truffethedog said…
Sparkle classic 3x14

Lucas'house or the Scott family house(seasons 5-7)?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Scott's house

Quinn or Haley ?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Defiantly Haley :)

Jamie or Sawyer?
over a year ago Drisina said…
Jamie

Season 3 or Season 6 ?
over a year ago Nibylandija said…
s3, duh.

Brooke/Owen or Brooke/Chase?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Dont like either much but ill go with Brase :)

Sophia Bush or Brooke Davis?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Brooke Davis.

Brooke slapping Rachel in season 3 or season 7?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
season 7 was amazing !

Who would YOU rather hit Alex or Milly?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Milly!!!!

LOL ok... Who would YOU rather hit Haley or Brooke?
over a year ago truffethedog said…
Not that I'd like to hit either of them but Haley if I have to choose. She'd take it better.

Who would YOU rather be- a basketball coach or a cofee owner in Tree Hill?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
eventhough id be rubbish, a basketball coach :D

errm Peyton/Chris or Haley/Lucas as a couple?
over a year ago Drisina said…
i think i will go Peyton/Chris cause Haley/Lucas would be to weird.

Alexander or Julian ?
over a year ago iluvnaley4evr said…
Julian

AU...victoria/paul or victoria/dan?
over a year ago notimetosleep said…
Victoria/Dan! I'm so waiting for it to happen in the real series also. They'd be fun together.

Keith and Jules' wedding or Lucas and Lindsey's?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!