One Tree Hill

One Tree Hill This or That?

tinkerbell247 posted on Oct 30, 2009 at 11:28PM
it's simple I've seen it on other spots, couldn't see it here and thought I'd start it.

All you have to do is choose which one you prefer then create the next one for the next fan to answer and so on.

To start: Lucas or Nathan?

One Tree Hill 1410 replies

Click here to write a response...

Showing Replies 151-200 of 1410

over a year ago norway94 said…
Jeyton

Nathan with Peyton or Brooke?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
peyton

More suprising death
Q or Keith?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Keith

Rachel and Peyton or Haley and Rachel?
over a year ago J-C said…
Rachel and Peyton.

Chris or Owen?
over a year ago emmett-girl said…
Chris

Season 1 or Season 7?
over a year ago Brucas4OTH said…
Season 1.

Lucas and Nathan or Haley and Quinn?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Lucas and Nathan

Peyton's southern accent or Brooke's raspy voice?
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
brooke's raspy voiceeeeee!!

haley's mugshot in season 3 or season 7 ??
over a year ago nikiebaby said…
Season 3

As a model:
Rachel or Alex
over a year ago Rosegirl94 said…
Rachel =)

Lily or Jamie?
over a year ago J-C said…
Lily!

Derek or Psycho Derek?
over a year ago comet-love said…
Phycho Derek!

Chase with Brooke or Chase with Mia?
over a year ago J-C said…
Chase with Brooke.

Mia singing solo or Mia in her old band?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago xxDUKE30xx said…
Mia singing solo.

Jake and Brooke or Jake and Haley?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Jake and Haley.

Brooke and Felix or Peyton and Pete?
over a year ago J-C said…
Peyton and Pete.

Lucas playing basketball or Lucas writing books?
over a year ago -carola-fan- said…
Lucas playing basket

Haley and Brooke or Haley and Peyton?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Haley/Brooke at the moment although it changes

Jamie = cute or Jamie = annoying
over a year ago Jessica4695 said…
Jamie=cute

Nathan's nipple piercing or Luke's "FUN" Tatoo ?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago J-C said…
Nathan's nipple piercing lol.

Carrie and Nathan (Narrie) or Karen and Andy (Kandy)?
over a year ago Jessica4695 said…
Karen and Andy

The sextape (brathan season 4) or Brooke in the time capsule (just the shirtless part) =D ?
over a year ago norway94 said…
wink
Brooke in the Time capsule :)

peyton angle of death gohst OR keith as a child gohst
over a year ago J-C said…
Peyton angel of death ghost.

Keith's Shop or Karen's Cafe?
over a year ago cissy121 said…
Karen's cafe.

Mike Wolf or Ellie?
over a year ago norway94 said…
Ellie

Lucas and Lindsay "wedding" OR Keith and Jules/Emily "wedding"
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Lucas and Lindsay "wedding"
Haley boxing or Peyton boxing?
over a year ago J-C said…
Peyton Boxing

Rachel calling Haley fat and short, or Haley slapping Rachel?

over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Haley slapping Rachel

Peyton being a bitch to Lindsey or Brooke being a bitch to Anna?
over a year ago -carola-fan- said…
Peyton being a bitch to Lindsey

Breyton or Laley?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Laley

Haley's poncho or Julian's funny hat ? (6.15)
over a year ago Rolemodel2011 said…
Haley's poncho for sure!!

Haley's first or second wedding dress?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Second wedding.

Lucas with Lindsey or Brooke with Felix?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Lucas with Lindsey

The pilot or the s6 finale (cause its the last one with the main 5)
over a year ago tmenne23 said…
the pilot!

haleys pregnancy or peytons
over a year ago TeamB_Forever said…
haleys pregnancy

Brachel or Breyton
over a year ago bright_angel said…
Breyton <3

Jake or Julian?
over a year ago leytonfaan_18 said…
Julian :)

Season 5 or 6?
over a year ago tinkerbell247 said…
Hmmm 6 I think.

Haley nickname: tutor girl of Haley bob
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Tutor Girl ♥

Mia and Chase's first date or Brooke and Julian's ?
over a year ago TeamB_Forever said…
hmmm.... Mia and Chase's first date!

Lucas and Peyton's first kiss or Jake and Peyton's?
over a year ago J-C said…
Lucas and Peyton's.

The Manface Lindsay song or Haley's Halo song?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Awww... Love both but Haley's Halo song.

Leyton motel scene or Naley bathroom scene?
over a year ago TeamB_Forever said…
Must admit Leyton motel scene

Haley or Nathan ?
over a year ago brucas_naley101 said…
rele hard but Haley :)

The Brucas tatoo or the naley braclet (not about the couple but about the actual thing)
over a year ago TeamB_Forever said…
Brucas tatoo

Brookes naked backseat scene or Rachels?
over a year ago ns_23 said…
Brooke's

Quinn or Taylor?
over a year ago othgg90210rule said…
Taylor!!!

Red Bedroom Records or Clothes Over Bros?
over a year ago Jessica4695 said…
Clothes Over Bros =)

I don't know if we already had this one :

Haley's tatoo or Brooke's ?
over a year ago cissy121 said…
Haley's..

Nathan with the Ravens or Nathan with the Charlotte Bobcats?
last edited over a year ago
over a year ago truffethedog said…
Nathan with the Ravens. I loved the basketball scenes :)

Brooke's house (seasons 5-7) or Peyton's house/room (seasons 1-4)?
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!